Best Bagels in Forked River

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Forked River, NJ at 721 S Main St

Baked Fresh Before Dawn, Every Single Day

Order online

Featured

View menu

Fresh Bagels. Real Ingredients. Every Morning.

Made from scratch before dawn in Forked River, NJ. No preservatives. No shortcuts.

Order online

Quality Ingredients

At All Star Bagel & Grill, we use only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients to make our bagels. Our flour is unbleached and unbromated, and we never use preservatives in our dough. Every bagel is crafted with filtered water and finished with premium toppings for exceptional freshness and flavor.

About our bagels

Menu & Specials

From our fresh, handcrafted bagels to hearty breakfast favorites, sandwiches, burgers, wraps, and daily specials, there's something for everyone. Made with quality ingredients and served fresh every day.

View Our Menu

Catering Made Easy

Bring the fresh flavors of our kitchen to your next gathering. Whether you're planning a business meeting, family celebration, or special event, our catering makes serving delicious food easy and stress-free.

Order Catering

Mouthwatering Bagels Gallery

Save Your Seat

Planning a breakfast, lunch, or get-together? Reserve your table today and enjoy fresh bagels, delicious meals, and friendly service in a welcoming atmosphere.

Reserve a Table

A Bagel Shop the Shore Deserves

All Star Bagel & Grill opened in Forked River to do one thing right: fresh bagels, made from scratch, every single morning. Chris and his wife are behind the counter every day — and that's exactly the point.

I was there on a Sunday. Very busy as usual. With a packed house the staff was still very pleasant and professional. I also lost my debit card in or around the establishment. The staff took the time to watch the camera and see if I had dropped my card inside the store.

Pete R.

All Star Bagel in Forked River is a hidden gem! The staff is always professional, friendly, and welcoming, making every visit a pleasure. The food is consistently fresh and absolutely delicious — from perfectly baked bagels to tasty breakfast sandwiches.

Carolyn H.

These are the best Bagels anywhere in NJ! The size is perfect, the taste amazing, the choices plentiful! The prices are great-talk about value! The atmosphere gets 5 stars because the family is so friendly and delightful. It is probably best that i don't live so close because I would go everyday!

Tera B.

We put in an order for pickup on a Sunday morning. They called me back to let me know they had run out of some of the flavors we wanted. No big deal. Picked up the order, got it home, and it was missing the cream cheese. Called them back, they apologized and we went back to the store.

Courtney L.